St. Denis Parish, Benton, MO, Founded 1840

St. Denis Parish Church, Benton MO (circa 2010)
St. Denis Parish Church, Benton MO (circa 2010)

General parish info

Contact info
Pastor: Fr. Michael Casteel
Administrative Assistant:
Lisa Spalding
RCIA Director:
Emily Seiler
Principal St Denis School:
Karen Powers (see ‘Parish related’ tab)

Phone: (573) 545-3864 — Fax: (573) 545-9185
Mailing address: St. Denis Church, PO Box 127, Benton, MO 63736-0127


All schedules subject to change. Please call parish offices above to verify.

Weekend Mass times

7 a.m., 10 a.m.

Daily Mass Times

7 p.m.
Wednesday – Friday
8 a.m.

Holy Days

7 p.m. Vigil
8 a.m.


10 a.m. to 10:45 a.m. during Lent
5:30 p.m. to 5:45 p.m. or by appointment


8:30 a.m. to 11 a.m., Fridays during Lent, with Benediction at 11 a.m.


6:45 p.m.

Office hours

Tuesday & Wednesday
8 a.m. – 4 p.m.

8 a.m. – 12 noon

Updated: 10-04-17


p64 1

Attractive land prices in southeast Missouri ($1.25 an acre) motivated Catholic pioneers to leave Canton, OH ($40.00 an acre) and travel the Ohio River by way of Cairo, IL, then up the Mississippi toward Commerce, MO. Most of this first group of pioneers originally came to America from Schirrhine, a village in Alsace, Lorraine. Trouble on the boat caused them to land and settle in Tywappity Bottoms, now called Texas Bend.

In 1839, a log church was built and dedicated to St. Francis de Sales. Outbreaks of malaria caused the settlement to seek a warmer, healthier climate. In 1841, the first group to leave settled near Benton. A donation of land enabled the community to again construct a log church in Benton near what is now highway 61.

Vincentian priests attended to the spiritual needs of the people even while the small Catholic community endured anti-Catholic sentiment. In 1845 the church was set on fire and burned to the ground by what was known as “The Know Nothing Spirit.” However, even before this event, the increasing population in Benton caused many to move farther west to the present site of New Hamburg. As that population grew, a church was built. Those who remained in Benton now had a distance of 10 or more miles to travel by horse and buggy to Mass.

In 1899, Frank L. Diebold willed six acres of land to the Benton Catholic community. This gift, augmented by a donation of $1,000 by Denis Diebold, enabled them to build a church that was dedicated to St. Dionysius (Denis) in 1904. A laywoman, Barbara Schumacher, conducted a school for 15 pupils until the Sisters of St. Francis of Mary Immaculate came in 1909. School enrollment grew to more than 100 students and has currently leveled out to the current enrollment of 80 students.

Priests served

Schmalle, Fr. Charles A., D, 1956, 1958
Donnelly, Fr. Thomas E., Sep 3, 1958 – Apr 22, 1960
Holmes, Fr. James, Apr 23, 1960 – Aug 16, 1966
Donovan, Fr. Francis P., Aug 17, 1966 – Jan 31, 1972
Monaghan, Fr. Justin D., Feb 1, 1972 – Oct 18, 1972
Kunkel, Fr. Raymond W., Aug 23, 1972 – Sep 14, 1975
Baker, Fr. John W., Sep 15, 1975 – Aug 31, 1980
Reynolds, Fr. James L., Sep 1, 1980 – Aug 14, 1984
Lukefahr, Fr. Oscar J., CM, D, 1984-1985, 1985-1986, 1986-1987, 1987-1988, 1988-1989, 1989-1990, 1990-1991
Basler, Fr. Arthur A., CM, D, 1991-1992, 1992-1993, 1993-1994
Cantore, Fr. John A., CM, D, 1991-1992
Varone, Fr. Normand G., Aug 17, 1994 – Jun 30, 2009
Casteel, Fr. Michael J., Jul 1, 2009 –

Above is compiled from diocesan archives.
“D” designates information compiled from The Catholic Directory or Year Book.

Parish related

GPS coordinates: N37° 05.944’ W089° 33.773’ (click here for map)
Physical Address: St. Denis Church, 135 N Winchester St, Benton, MO


St. Denis School
106 N Winchester, PO Box 189, Benton, MO 63736-0189

Principal: Karen Powers
(573) 545-3017 — Fax: (573) 545-9185

Web site:


Attends to: St. Lawrence Parish, New Hamburg, MO

Share This: